Restoring one of Forest Park's oldest houses

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By John Rice

Columnist / Staff reporter

It only took fifteen years and $150,000 but Bob Cox is proud to say the renovation of his historic home at 419 Marengo is complete. Bob will be sharing the wisdom he acquired in a workshop called "Your Old House 101" May 19 at 4:00 p.m. The event is being hosted by the Historical Society of Forest Park at St. Peter's Church.

Bob estimates that 80 percent of Forest Park's homes will soon be turning 100.

"Bring photos of your house," he advises participants in the workshop.

Cox counts his 2,800 square foot Victorian as one of the town's three oldest houses. It originally belonged to Joseph Carney and sat on the corner of Marengo and Madison. Carney moved it in 1918, presumably to escape the noisy business district.

Carney was one of the town's first Irish immigrants arriving here from County Wexford in the early 1850's. He once owned forty acres of prime real estate but sold off his subdivision, piece by piece. In 1959, Carney's grandson sold the Italianate-style house to Bob's dad for $23,500.

It served the Cox family well over the years, comfortably accommodating nine family members. The house was adaptable to every situation, including when Bob's mom used a wheelchair. It even survived a devastating fire in 1987.

After his dad passed away in 1993, Bob moved in to take care of his mom. In 1997, he vowed to renovate the house in memory of his father. Thankfully, his dad had "cocooned" the house's interior with paneling and wallpaper. Bob discovered there were Celtic stencils underneath. The first major project, though, was to convert it back to a single-family home. Like many houses in town, it had been turned into a two-flat during World War II.

Besides transforming rooms, like the upstairs kitchen, Bob faced a major headache replacing the roof. It had structural damage and became the most expensive part of the project. There was also a complication when a contractor was upgrading the electrical service. The old wires had been run through the gas pipes and the gas was still on! The renovation included replacing lead water pipes with copper.

Bathrooms were modified, a tin ceiling was installed in the kitchen and Bob added a basement bar. Though he used contractors for the big projects, Bob helped with demolition, painting and repairing windows. The final touch was removing the green shingles and repairing and painting the clapboard siding.

Bob admitted the construction was hard on his wife and kids but ultimately added to their comfort. He had two furnaces and two hot water heaters installed and cut down on drafts with caulking and new storm windows. Throughout the project, he remained committed to staying in Forest Park. "The value of living here is greater than the value of selling it." His final goal is to have the house added to the National Register of Historic Places. If it qualifies, it will be named for the man who purchased it in 1959, The Robert Daniel Cox House.

Reader Comments

7 Comments - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

Rick Sallee from La Grange pk.  

Posted: May 13th, 2018 11:36 AM

Congratulations Bob-i looks beautiful .I wish I could have done that with Coras' house at 822 Ferdinand which dates to 1917 when my grandparents bought it for $5000.00. I still have the original bill of sale ( and LOTS of other stuff ) . So sorry to hear about the society thing. Maybe we can talk about it one day.

street view  

Posted: June 1st, 2013 2:15 AM

@dan miller -- here you go:

Dan Miller  

Posted: May 31st, 2013 9:03 PM

I would love to see some exterior pictures of the house.

Bob Cox from Forerst Park  

Posted: May 12th, 2013 9:31 AM

Justin, the earliest visual mention of the Carney House is around1870, since there are no building records left , i have always found that a circa estimted date can work. The oldest parts of town where other old houses ( 120 years plus) are on the north side of town aka Harlem. Bring a picture Sunday , the workshop tools and references are exactly what you can use to discover how old your house may be.

Justin from Forest Park  

Posted: May 10th, 2013 2:11 PM

This article isn't very old is this house? Also, the article refers to this being among the three oldest houses in sure would be nice to know the others (and their ages). Being a proud owner of a 110+ year old house myself I want to know where we stack up! Bob, if you ever run out of things to renovate at your house you can come start on my house :)

Jennifer from Forest Park  

Posted: May 9th, 2013 1:32 PM

The picture is beautiful and that's just the hallway! It looks like you did a wonderful and loving restoration.

Bob Cox from Forest Park  

Posted: May 8th, 2013 7:50 AM

Old home improvements may start out as "I" actions but the most sucessfull end as "we" actions. Mine is no exception.Our project would have never been sustainable without the real estate and financial expertise of my wife Sharon Anderson- Cox, Senior Vice President , Inland Group, Oakbrook Il , 30 +year resident in Forest Park, and the nice lady who sits on our front porch saying "Hi" to passer bys...

Facebook Connect

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Forest Park.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad

Classified Ad