A man in uniform saluting
Forest Park Police Department Lt. Dan Miller at the American Legion Post 414 Memorial Day Ceremony on May 27, 2024 | Erica Benson

After six months, Gold Shield Detective Agency has concluded its investigation into an incident involving Lt. Dan Miller of the Forest Park Police Department. On April 27, Miller, while off duty in North Riverside, brandished a gun and pulled 18-year-old Breanna Pantoja from her car after it slid onto the curb in rainy weather. North Riverside police later released Pantoja without charges.  

A press release announcing the end of the investigation, sent to the Review by Village Administrator Rachell Entler on Nov. 10, said Miller violated two Forest Park Police Department policies. As a result, he will be suspended for five days without pay, then reassigned to administrative duties. The village is also requiring Miller to complete training specific to the department policies he violated.  

“The Forest Park Police and the Village of Forest Park are committed to maintaining the highest standards of professionalism, accountability and public trust. When violations of departmental policies occur, appropriate corrective action is taken to address the conduct and reinforce expectations for all department personnel,” the press release said. 

Though Gold Shield determined Miller violated Forest Park policy, North Riverside and Forest Park police both reported that his actions were within his authority as an officer and the department’s policy and procedures. 

Entler told the Review that the Forest Park police chief issued Miller’s suspension and reassigned his duties after consulting with the village attorney, mayor, and village administrator. 

According to Police Chief Dan Pater, Miller was moved indefinitely to his new administrative role in May by then-Chief Ken Gross, who retired in September. Miller was on paid administrative leave until Nov. 13. In his administrative role, Miller will supervise civilian employees in records, parking and communications, plus take care of the department’s vehicle fleet.  

Pater said the department’s three lieutenants — which oversee patrol, administrative and investigation — all have administrative duties. While Miller was the lieutenant that oversaw patrol, he will now oversee administrative duties. His reassignment does not affect the patrol division numbers, according to Entler. 

“We remain committed to ensuring that all members of our department are held accountable for their actions and that appropriate measures are taken when our standards are not met,” Pater said in the press release. “Our goal is to continue fostering public confidence through transparency, professionalism, and ongoing training.” 

After the April 27 incident, Pantoja submitted a formal complaint with the Forest Park Police Department. In June, Pantoja submitted a pre-litigation claim against the village for alleged injuries and damages from the traffic stop. The village denied its employees engaged in improper conduct but, to avoid future litigation and legal fees, paid Pantoja and her counsel $45,000. 

Gold Shield’s report 

With the Nov. 10 press release, the Forest Park Police Department has released a 51-page redacted copy of Gold Shield’s investigative report, which was submitted to the village on Oct. 13. The village hired Gold Shield to start investigating the incident in June, after the Cook County Sheriff’s Office still hadn’t started its investigation.  

Local officials determined the appropriate course of action for Miller’s employment after Gold Shield reported that he violated Forest Park Policy 100 and 300.  

Forest Park Policy 100 says that an officer “is vested by law with a duty to maintain public order and make lawful arrest even while off duty.” It also says that an off duty officer “should take action after considering the tactical situation concerning his own safety, the safety of others and the possible liability of the department.”  

Based on this policy, Gold Shield President Jimmy Lee Jr. said in the report, “It is my opinion that the arrest of Ms. Pantoja was not based on probable cause, and therefore not lawful. … In my opinion, [Miller] should have waited for the proper agencies and on duty officers to respond to take appropriate actions. The manner of driving of Ms. Pantoja as described by Lt. Miller did not, in my opinion, rise to the level of exigent circumstances, considering the dangerous tactical situation created by the driving technique used by Lt. Miller. His action increased the risk to himself, Ms. Pantoja and other citizens.”  

Gold Shield determined Miller also violated Forest Park Policy 300, Response to Resistance and Aggression, which says use of force must be reasonable and necessary. Lee said these violations include pointing a gun at Pantoja, physically removing her from her car, getting her hands behind her back, and placing her in handcuffs. 

“I do not believe Lt. Miller’s use of force was necessary or justified. If not necessary, then the force used to follow was not reasonable,” Lee wrote in the Gold Shield report. “The manner in which Lt. Miller approached Ms. Pantoja was, in my opinion, unnecessary. Forcibly stopping and blocking her vehicle, using his personal vehicle, dressed in civilian clothing, and without clearly identifying himself as a police officer with his badge clearly displayed, was unreasonable.”  

A section of Forest Park Policy 300 mandates that police report use of force efforts accurately, completely and timely.  

Miller did not fill out a Frontline Use of Force Form, which is required under the department’s Response to Resistance and Aggression policy. Use of force includes the pointing of firearms at an individual and handcuffing or escorting a complaint, though “this does not include drawing a firearm and maintaining [it] at the low-ready position,” according to the policy.  

“Miller was required to document that he pointed his firearm at Ms. Pantoja. He failed to,” the Gold Shield report said, though he included in his police report that he pulled out his handgun and later holstered his weapon. 

Local police findings  

Separate from the Gold Shield investigation, a North Riverside police detective was assigned to investigate the incident, though that investigation didn’t include an interview with Pantoja or Gold Shield’s interrogation of Miller.  

North Riverside police reported that, according to Illinois statute, “Any person may arrest another when he has reasonable grounds to believe that an offense other than an ordinance violation is being committed.” They added, “It is this police department’s belief that Lt. Miller had reasonable grounds to believe that a criminal offense had been committed and acted within the authority provided by law.”  

After Miller’s interrogation, Gold Shield learned that Chief Gross ordered a convening of the Forest Park Police Department’s internal Response to Resistance and Aggression Review Board — which the chief can request to investigate use of force incidents. Deputy Chief Chris Chin served as chairperson, while Pater was training officer, along with Lt. Nick Defors and Sgt. Michael Spangnolo. Officer Cristal Avila served as a peer on the board. 

According to Gold Shield, “The assignment and timing of this review board was unusual. The board met on July 16, 2026, over two months after the April 27, 2026 incident — after the decision was made to utilize an outside investigative service to review the incident and two days after Lt. Miller was given notice of his upcoming formal interrogation.”  

Per policy, police are required to inform the officer who will be discussed at the Response to Resistance and Aggression Review Board meeting, in case they want to have a representative present throughout the process. Chin said a notice was put in Miller’s internal mailbox, which he didn’t have access to while on paid administrative leave. None of the board members contacted Miller about the meeting. 

After only 20 minutes of reviewing police reports, social media video, 911 audio recordings and department policy 300, Forest Park’s Response to Resistance and Aggression Review Board found that “Lt. Miller’s actions were within department policy and procedures,” according to the board’s documented findings report. There were no notes taken at the meeting, according to Gold Shield. 

On Aug. 6, Lee met with Gross and Chin to discuss the review board meeting. Gross said he called for the meeting because the Miller incident was high profile, but there was a delay because of short staffing and large workload. Gross said he was on vacation May 22 through May 31, and Chin was on vacation May 16 through May 31. 

Miller said in his Gold Shield interrogation that his actions shouldn’t be subject to a Response to Resistance and Aggression Review Board because he didn’t fire his weapon, only pointed it. According to the Gold Shield report, “He specifically testified that Chief Gross has frequently espoused his opinion on this issue to the officers of the department.”  

Miller’s violations  

During Gold Shield’s official interrogation of Miller, he said he believed Pantoja was involved in a hit-and-run accident, a Class A misdemeanor. 

Miller was at Cermak and 1st Avenue, intending to continue west on Cermak, when Pantoja turned south down 1st Avenue at the intersection. Because of wet conditions and her driving a car that was new to her, Pantoja said in an interview with Gold Shield that she lost control of the car, which sideslipped and stopped on the sidewalk on the southwest corner of the intersection. 

Miller maneuvered to follow Pantoja south on 1st Avenue after he heard what he thought was a traffic accident.  

“I believe that [Miller] had a reasonable belief that a hit-and-run may be in progress at that point,” Lee wrote in the Gold Shield report. But “as a police officer, he is trained and required to continually reassess situations, develop additional probable cause or eliminate probable cause as new circumstances or information is obtained.” 

While following Pantoja down 1st Avenue for about a mile, “Lt. Miller should have observed the absences of damage on the vehicle consistent with a crash,” Lee wrote in the report. “As he was providing this vehicle description [to 911], he would have, or should have, been able to observe any potential vehicle damage, a critical element of any hit-and-run investigation. … With the lack of observable damage to the vehicle and a reasonable continued reevaluation of the circumstances known to Lt. Miller, it should have become less probable for him to believe the vehicle had caused any harmful events.” 

When Miller caught up to Pantoja on 1st Avenue, he cut her off with his car, boxing her in. 

Forest Park policy on vehicle pursuits and emergency vehicle operations defines “boxing-in,” but Miller said during his interrogation that he was only following Pantoja’s car, not in pursuit of it. Miller acknowledged that his personal vehicle is not an authorized emergency vehicle. 

“He incorrectly asserted that, based on department policy, vehicles other than marked or semi-marked [police vehicles] may initiate a pursuit,” the Gold Shield report said. “A private citizen vehicle, even being operated by a police officer, is not authorized to begin a vehicle pursuit.”  

Gold Shield determined Miller’s boxing-in technique “does not seem necessary or reasonable.” And the way that he blocked lanes with his personal vehicle increased hazards to himself, Pantoja and other drivers.  

Gold Shield also determined that Miller didn’t present himself as a police officer at an appropriate time.  

“Not knowing that Lt. Miller was in fact a police officer could have caused a passing on-duty officer, another off-duty police officer or a legally armed private citizen to take a defensive action, placing Ms. Pantoja, Lt. Miller and nearby citizens at risk,” the Gold Shield report said.   

Though Miller announced himself as police, and Pantoja made conflicting statements about whether he identified himself as an officer, she says she asked to see his badge and he refused. Pantoja later told Gold Shield in an interview that she would’ve been more cooperative if Miller had shown his badge. 

“It is likely that Ms. Pantoja requested to see the badge and it was not displayed, even after she was in custody,” Lee said in the report.  

In the police report he filed, Miller says he lifted his shirt to show his badge and gun. The shirt had USA on the front and TRUMP 45 on the back, with the tail extending about six inches below his beltline, according to the Gold Shield report. Body worn camera footage shows Miller’s shirt wrapped behind his gun, but blocking his badge from view.  

“While he moves, the badge is only intermittently and partially visible. The badge would not be visible to someone in front of Lt. Miller,” the Gold Shield report says. 

When Gold Shield interviewed Miller on July 22, he said, “If I could Monday morning quarterback this whole thing, the one thing I would have done is I would have unclipped my badge and approached with my gun out with my badge in hand and have one hand on my gun. But that’s not what I did.”  

In the 911 dispatch recording, Miller described the driver of the vehicle he was pursuing as “Hispanic with piercings all over” and can be heard saying, “Police, show me your hands. Turn the car off,” the latter command which he gives three more times. Miller orders Pantoja to get out of the car twice, then says, “Put your f****** hands on the roof.”  

“Based on the verbal exchange, it was clear that Ms. Pantoja was not immediately aware of the reasons she was stopped,” the Gold Shield report said. 

During interrogation, Miller said he didn’t recall if he told Pantoja she was under arrest, though he said she was in custody and not free to leave when he stopped her.  

“Absent probable cause, authority for an arrest was not present for a police officer or private citizen,” the Gold Shield report said. The report continues to say that there must be a “harmful event” involving personal injury or property damage for an incident to be considered a traffic crash. Since it didn’t qualify as such, Pantoja wasn’t required to stay on scene or make a police report.  

“Based on the review of these events, Ms. Pantoja could have potentially been charged with the petty offense of Driving Too Fast For Conditions by an on-duty police officer from North Riverside or an on-duty officer from within the police district. A petty offense cannot be enforced through a citizen’s arrest,” the report said.  

In reviewing Miller’s training records, Gold Shield found that, on Jan. 21, 2025, Miller failed his Duty to Disclose policy training and, 20 seconds later, passed the same training. Miller also failed his first Vehicle Pursuit and Emergency Driving policy test on Dec. 31, 2024, and passed about 3 minutes later. Also on New Year’s Eve in 2024, Miller failed his Duty to Intervene policy test twice before passing it less than 3 minutes after the first test. 

“This situation raises the question of understanding the policy as opposed to simply learning the correct response to test questions,” Gold Shield said in the report.  

At the end of Miller’s interrogation with Gold Shield, he was asked if he had any additional comments, to which he responded that he believed “that the reason he was being investigated was based on his clothing and license plate information related to President Trump,” the Gold Shield report says. “He also recalled incidents that he was involved in during his career which he believes did not involve the level of scrutiny or the amount of time required to investigate the incident.”